PART 2: What The Boys Overheard
The twins began bouncing up and down. "I’m M!" "I’m L!" Apparently, they considered this the most wonderful development of their lives.
I was livid. "They had beautiful hair." Henry replied, "It grows." "You didn’t even ask me."
"Emma, they’re haircuts." "They are alphabet haircuts." Max giggled. "M is me!" Leo twirled around. "L is me!"
Henry gave a shrug. "See? Happy customers."
With the boys standing there, I was far too angry to have the argument properly. I told him, "We’re discussing this later."
His smile faded. "Fine."
For the rest of the evening, the twins admired each other’s heads. In the bath, they couldn’t stop feeling the letters. Around 8:30 p.m., I tucked them in: Max beside the window and Leo beside the door, exactly where they always slept.
At approximately 11:30, I checked the baby monitor. Both boys were asleep. Then Leo climbed from his bed.
He shook Max awake, and the two whispered together. Max got up with Pickle and his blanket. They traded beds. I assumed the letters had inspired another silly game about swapping identities.
Then Leo turned straight toward the monitor and whispered, "Shhh." At that instant, the bedroom door opened. Henry entered. And I spotted the clippers.

Now I was in that room myself, discovering that the missing letters had something to do with words our sons should never have overheard. I looked at Henry. "What did they hear?"
He rested back against the wall. "After you left this afternoon, I called my brother." "Tom?" He nodded. "Why?" Looking uncomfortable, he answered, "Because I knew you’d be mad."
"Correct." "I wanted someone to tell me it wasn’t as stupid as it looked." "Did he?" "No." I nearly smiled.
Henry kept his eyes on the floor. "He laughed for like two minutes." "Appropriate." "Then I told him why I did it."
Apparently, the boys had been standing in the hallway, quiet for a change. Henry hadn’t realized they were there. He had told Tom, "I know Emma thinks it’s funny, but I hate that I can’t tell them apart."
My almost-smile disappeared. Henry went on. "I told him sometimes I look at them and panic." "Why?" He paused. "Because I’m their dad."
That didn’t explain it, and he knew that. "I should know which one is which." "Henry—" "No. Let me finish."
He glanced toward the beds. "I know who they are." His voice cracked a little. "I know Max likes dinosaurs. I know Leo hates getting water in his face. I know which one asks for the blue cup and which one wants the green one."
Then he looked at me again. "But when they’re standing together and neither one is talking, sometimes I don’t know." I answered, "They’re identical twins." "I know." "Other people mix them up." "I’m not other people."
There it was: the shame he had been carrying beneath all those jokes.
He continued, "I told Tom that someday they’re going to realize their own dad has to guess." I felt awful. It had never occurred to me that he wasn’t sharing our amusement. Henry had laughed because the rest of us were laughing.
He said, "I told him maybe I’m just bad at this." From his bed, Max whispered, "Bad daddy."
Henry crouched beside him immediately. "No." Max looked anxious. Henry brushed his cheek. "No, buddy. That’s not what I meant." "But you said it." "I said something stupid because I was upset."
From the other bed, Leo leaned forward. "Then you made the M and L." Henry nodded. "I did."
Max said, "We didn’t like them." I stared at both children. "You two acted as if you loved them." Leo shrugged. "We liked them first." Max added, "Then we heard Daddy."
I asked, "So you shaved them off?" Leo nodded. "Because Daddy knows us." Henry lowered his gaze, and tears began gathering in my eyes.
Max climbed down from his bed and stopped directly in front of his father. "Who am I?" Henry didn’t answer right away.
