PART 1: The Clippers In The Dark
My husband sometimes struggled to distinguish our identical twins, so he shaved their initials into their hair. I assumed that was the worst part—until our sons exposed something he had kept hidden. Henry wasn’t what sent me racing upstairs. The clippers were. I was already out of bed before I had time to think.
"Henry!" I hurried up the stairs two at a time. When I reached the boys’ bedroom, he was standing between their beds with the clippers in one hand. Both children were awake. Leo occupied Max’s bed, and Max occupied Leo’s. They were both grinning.
I pushed open the door. "What are you doing?" Henry startled so badly that the clippers almost fell from his hand. "Jeez, Emma." I stared at what he was holding. "Why do you have those?"
The twins burst into laughter. Henry glanced at them, then back at me, and let out a sigh. "They switched." "I can see that." "No. I mean the letters."
I looked more closely. Max pointed to his head, except the M had vanished. Leo no longer had an L either. The enormous, absurd letters Henry had fashioned by leaving sections longer than the surrounding hair had been almost entirely buzzed off.
I turned to my husband. "You shaved them again?" "No." Leo announced proudly, "We did." My stomach sank. "You what?"
Max pointed at his brother. "He did mine." Leo pointed back. "Then he did mine." I shut my eyes. For one long second, I reminded myself that yelling wouldn’t bring their hair back.
"You used your father’s clippers?" Both boys nodded. Henry grimaced.
"They found them on our bathroom counter while we were downstairs earlier. Seems like they’d already taken turns shaving off the letters before bedtime, and neither of us noticed until I checked on them."
I fixed my eyes on him. "Why were they somewhere they could reach them?" "They were on the counter." "They’re four." "I know." "We have discussed this." "I know." I pointed at his hand. "Then why are you holding them?" Henry sighed. "I found the clippers on the floor when I came in. I was about to take them away."

The whole situation had become so ridiculous that I couldn’t decide whether to cry or laugh. Instead, I settled on anger. "Nobody is touching another hair on either child’s head tonight." Max frowned. "But Mama—" "No." "It looks bad." "It looked bad six hours ago."
Henry coughed into his hand. I spun toward him. "Do not." "I’m not saying anything." "You made this problem." "I know."
Leo looked from one of us to the other. Then he said, "We had to." That brought me up short. "What do you mean, you had to?" He glanced at Max, who drew his blanket up beneath his chin. Neither boy replied.
I lowered myself onto the edge of the closest bed. "Guys." They recognized that voice—the serious one. "Why did you shave the letters off?" Leo glanced at Henry before looking back at me. "Because Daddy was sad."
Henry’s expression shifted. I turned to him. "What?" "Nothing." But Leo kept going. "Daddy said he was bad at being our daddy." Henry closed his eyes.
I stared at him. "When did you say that?" "I didn’t say it to them." Max sat upright. "We heard you." My husband’s face fell. That was how a conversation began that we should have had years before.
My name is Emma. Henry and I had been married seven years, and our identical sons, Max and Leo, were four. By identical, I mean strangers could scarcely tell them apart. They had matching blond curls, blue eyes, dimples, and height. Even their voices were alike.
To me, though, they were entirely different children. Max was the quieter one, observing before he joined in. He slept wrapped around a green dinosaur called Pickle. Leo hardly stopped talking and slept on his back with his arms thrown above his head.
Max couldn’t stand strawberries. Leo would finish a whole carton if I allowed it. When Max was nervous, he wrinkled his nose. Leo rubbed his left ear. From the other side of a playground, I could identify either child. Henry couldn’t—not reliably.
For years, we had made a running joke of it. "Which one is this?" I would ask, holding one of the boys. Henry would narrow his eyes. "Max." "Wrong." "Leo."
Sometimes our sons intentionally exchanged shirts. Sometimes they responded to each other’s names. They found it hysterical. Most of the time, I did too. What I hadn’t understood was how deeply Henry took it to heart.
He would address Max as Leo and instantly look mortified. At birthday celebrations, he sometimes paused before passing a plate to one of them. At preschool pickup, he waited for a boy to speak before committing to a name.
One teacher once teased him, "Still don’t know your own kids?" Henry laughed, and I joined in. I wish I hadn’t.
The afternoon before that late-night encounter with the clippers, I went out for groceries. Henry remained home with the twins. When I came back, both boys raced toward me, and I nearly let the shopping bags fall.
Their lovely curls had disappeared. They hadn’t merely been shortened. They were gone, buzzed close to their scalps. On top of each head, Henry had left enough hair to spell one enormous letter. M. L.
I stood staring. "Henry!" He came out of the kitchen looking pleased with himself. "Problem solved." "Problem?" "Nobody can mix them up now."
I set down the groceries. "You shaved letters into our children."
