Part 2: Who Do You Want to Be Today?

I wanted to hear her explain the rules before she realized she’d already broken them.
But first, I remembered something I’d almost forgotten about myself.
Nine years earlier, I had earned my living painting children’s faces at birthday parties.
Parents often walked up to me with instructions.
“Make her a princess. It matches her dress.”
“And what does she want?”
“Does it matter?”
“To me, it does.”
I had always asked every child the same question.
“Who do you want to be today?”
Once, at an expensive birthday party, a little girl climbed into my chair.
“Dragon,” she announced.
“Green or red?”
“Green. With scary teeth!”
Her mother appeared behind her.
“Absolutely not. She’s supposed to be a princess.”
“But Mommy…”
“We paid for professional photographs.”
I glanced at the girl.
“How about we try the dragon first?”
Her mother sighed.
“Fine. But make it cute.”
When I finished, the girl let out a roar.
“Mommy, look! I’m a dragon!”
Another child dashed over. “I want one too!”
“Me too!” someone shouted.
Before long, three children were wearing dragons.
That girl’s grin stayed with me for years.
Then Victoria was born.
I slowly stopped working parties and eventually became a graphic designer working from home.
I loved my daughter fiercely. Perhaps too fiercely.
Before first grade, I took Victoria shopping.
“Mommy! A dinosaur backpack!”
“Look at this one, sweetheart. All the girls have something similar.”
“But this one has spikes!”
“Wouldn’t you rather have the pretty pink one?”
She hesitated.
“Okay, Mommy.”
I bought matching hair bows, too.
When the festival announcement came, Victoria showed it to me.
“Lily and Emma want butterflies!”
“Would you like one too?”
She hesitated.
“Maybe.”
“Butterflies are lovely, sweetheart.”
“Okay, Mommy.”
I smiled, sure we’d made the perfect choice.
Standing in that hallway now, I remembered my old notebook.
But something more urgent than nostalgia needed my attention.
I wanted that teacher to explain herself.
I went back to Principal Harris’s office.
“Mrs. Parker, is Victoria ready to leave?”
“Almost. First, I’d like you to hear something.”
“What happened?”
“Ms. Collins refused to paint Victoria’s face.”
“Did she explain why?”
“She told my daughter makeup wouldn’t make girls like her pretty.”
Principal Harris frowned.
“That’s a serious allegation.”
“I understand. I’m not asking you to punish someone without hearing her.”
“What are you asking?”
“Could you come to the painting table in about three minutes? Don’t introduce me.”
“Why?”
“I want to ask her a question before she knows whose mother I am.”
Principal Harris thought it over.
“All right. But I’ll intervene if necessary.”
“That’s fair.”
Victoria sat with the school secretary, flipping through a picture book.
“Mommy?”
“Just a few minutes, sweetheart.”
“Then movies?”
“Absolutely.”
I headed back to the festival.
The teacher was wiping off her brushes.
“Excuse me,” I said pleasantly. “Could you paint a little golden crown on my cheek?”
“On you?”
“Unless you see another thirty-five-year-old princess waiting behind me.”
She laughed.
“Sorry. This station is for children.”
“That’s disappointing. I’ve been practicing my royal wave.”
“Maybe next year.”
“Who makes the rules?”
“The school.”
“And the children choose their own designs?”
“Of course. That’s the whole point.”
“Even if you don’t like their choice?”
She frowned.
“Why wouldn’t I?”
“Just making sure. So you wouldn’t refuse a little girl simply because she looks different?”
“Absolutely not. Every child is welcome here.”
She had no idea she’d just contradicted herself.
I smiled.
“That’s interesting. Because a six-year-old girl asked you for a butterfly today. And you told her makeup wouldn’t make girls like her pretty.”
Her smile disappeared.
“Who told you that?”
“Does it matter?”
“Children misunderstand things.”
“Then help me understand.”
“I was explaining that appearance isn’t everything.”
“By telling her she wasn’t pretty?”
“I never said those exact words.”
“What did you say?”
She crossed her arms. “I told her that face paint doesn’t change how someone looks underneath.”
“Why would a six-year-old need that lesson?”
“She was getting upset.”
“Before or after you refused her?”
The teacher faltered.
“Look, some children need realistic expectations.”
My fingers tightened around my purse.
“Expectations about what?”
“Victoria kept saying she wanted to look like the other girls. I was trying to explain that a painted butterfly wouldn’t change what makes her different.”
“And you thought telling her she wasn’t pretty would help?”
“I thought it was better than giving her false hope.”
“False hope?” I repeated. “She’s six. She wanted a butterfly.”
“You’re twisting my words.”
“Then explain them to the principal.”
Ms. Collins spun around.
“Principal Harris!”
“I heard enough.”
“Nothing inappropriate.”
I turned to face her. “I’m Victoria’s mother.”
Her expression shifted. “Oh.”
“Yes. Oh.”
