Part 1: Rather Die Than Marry Her

“God, I hope never. I’d rather die than marry her.”
My boyfriend said this in front of twenty-three guests, laughing so hard he nearly spilled his whiskey. The laughter wasn’t the cruelest part. He was pointing straight at me. Three hours later, I would learn that the man who thought marriage to me was worse than death had sent a mortgage lender my financial records without my consent. At 9:47 that Friday evening, though, I knew nothing about the loan.
I only knew that someone I had loved for almost three years had just declared a lifetime with me unbearable in public. I am Mara Ellison, a thirty-three-year-old manufacturing engineer who had apparently become the greatest embarrassment in Louisville, Kentucky. We were at a trendy NuLu cocktail lounge celebrating our friends’ engagement. Guests showed off expensive watches and ordered drinks that cost more than my weekly groceries.
Drew Kessler, my boyfriend, stood beside me in the navy birthday blazer I had given him. He was handsome, confident, and completely at ease. Drew always seemed relaxed when somebody else was paying. Our friend Gavin Roark had just announced his engagement to Elise, his longtime partner. While congratulations were still circulating, Drew’s best friend, Parker Mays, raised his glass.
“All right, Drew. Gavin’s officially off the market. When are you finally going to propose to Mara?”
Several guests turned toward us. Someone chuckled. Drew’s grip at my waist tightened for a moment, and I expected an affectionate answer. Instead came the words that ended us.
“God, I hope never. I’d rather die than marry her.”
Uneasy laughter broke out around the table. Parker slapped the bar. Gavin set down his glass. Elise looked appalled. Drew, enjoying the attention, kept going.
“Come on, you guys know me. I’m not built for that boring suburban husband routine. Mortgage payments, grocery lists, mowing the lawn every Saturday.”
He glanced at me.
“Mara’s great. Seriously. She’s dependable. But being married to someone that predictable?”
He shook his head for effect.
“That’s a life sentence.”
Someone murmured his name. He ignored it.
“Besides, why buy the cow when the milk’s already free?”
Something inside me shifted then. It didn’t break, and it didn’t explode. It changed. I suddenly remembered every bill I had covered when Drew lost his job. The late nights I spent preparing him for interviews. The celebrations I arranged for his promotions. The pricey dinners when his wallet conveniently went missing. And all our conversations about buying a first home.
Just two days earlier, he had kissed my forehead in the kitchen and whispered, “I can’t wait to build a future with you.”
Now he was ridiculing the misery that same future supposedly held. I lowered my eyes to my champagne. And smiled.
“You’re absolutely right, Drew.”
He blinked in surprise.
“What?”
“I said you’re right.”
I put the glass down on the bar.
“Nobody should have to spend their life with someone they don’t want to marry.”
His grin slipped.
“Mara, come on.”
“No, really. Thank you for being honest.”
I pulled forty dollars from my purse and left it beside my drink. I looked him in the eye.
“Don’t worry. You won’t have to marry me.”
I walked toward the door. Behind me, Drew gave a nervous laugh.
“Seriously? You’re doing this?”
I kept walking.
“Mara!”
I reached the entrance.
“Baby, it was a joke!”
I stopped only long enough to face him.
“Then here’s another one.”
The group went silent.
“Congratulations. You’re single.”
I stepped outside before he could answer. The cool night air met me as cars passed and music drifted from nearby restaurants. My hands were shaking, but I refused to cry. Not there. Not in public. My phone buzzed before I could even order a car. Drew: Are you seriously embarrassing me over a joke? Another text followed. Drew: Get back in here. You’re making everyone uncomfortable. And another.
Drew: We have important things to do Monday. Don’t start drama now. Monday. That word hit harder than his insults at the bar. We supposedly had an appointment with a mortgage broker Monday morning. Or so he had told me. We had been considering a four-bedroom house in a quiet suburb. I loved its wraparound porch, two-car garage, and workshop space. The listing price was $438,000. I had spent seven years saving for a down payment.
Drew had spent seven months imagining how he would use the garage.
Whenever I asked about his contribution, he kissed my cheek and said, “We’re a team, sweetheart. Don’t turn everything into a spreadsheet.”
That should have warned me. But I trusted him. I called a ride and watched the city lights flicker past the back-seat window. Drew had called eleven times by the time I got to our place. I let every call ring out. His expensive leather shoes sat by the sofa, and three empty energy-drink cans and bills he had promised to pay were scattered across the coffee table.
I went into the spare bedroom Drew called my “little engineering cave.”
My laptop sat on the worktable. My motorcycle helmet rested beside a toolbox. My phone showed a new email from Bluegrass Home Lending. The subject line made my stomach turn. Your Mortgage Prequalification Documents Have Been Received. I stared at it. Nothing was supposed to be submitted before Monday. I opened it. It confirmed receipt of my pay slips, employment verification, and available down-payment details. My pulse raced.
I had provided none of it. Another detail jumped out. The inquiry listed me as the primary borrower. Drew appeared only as an additional occupant. I read it three times. The boyfriend who had mocked the idea of marrying me had secretly pursued a mortgage built on my income. Without telling me. The phone rang again. This time it wasn’t Drew. It was Elise. I answered.
“Mara?” she whispered. “Please tell me you haven’t signed anything for that house.”
My mouth went dry.
“No. Why?”
Silence stretched out. Elise’s next words sent me sinking into a chair.
“Because Drew told Gavin what he plans to do after you buy it.”
I gripped the phone.
“What does he plan to do?”
Elise drew an unsteady breath.
“Mara, you need to hear this from someone who was there.”
Then she told me everything…
