EPILOGUE: Her Chair
October has come around again. Last Saturday, Maisie turned thirteen.
We celebrated in the backyard with burgers, hot dogs, potato salad, and another purple-frosted Kroger cake. Sam played guitar. Noah flew home on leave in uniform, and Maisie screamed so loudly at his arrival that neighbors called to check on us.
Not one uninvited person knocked.
After everybody left that evening, I began clearing the dining room.
At the end of our table, nearest the kitchen, stood Brenda’s chair. She had occupied it for sixteen years. Since she left, nobody had used it—not once in eleven years. We simply pulled out the other eight chairs and left hers tucked away.
I had hardly registered the habit. It was merely the shape of our lives. That night, Maisie was sitting there.
The old Facebook Marketplace tablet rested in her lap. Its screen now had a small corner crack, and stickers covered its case. She was drawing a horse, using the skills Grace had taught her.
She glanced up. “Is this okay?” she asked. “Me sitting here?”
I stood looking at my thirteen-year-old daughter in Brenda’s chair, at the end of our table in the little Pinecrest Drive split-level.
I remembered the night Brenda disappeared: seven children crying in the dark, Maisie gripping her crib and screaming for her mama. I remembered my wife standing in our bedroom, hands on her hips, telling me I had never given her the life she deserved.

For eleven years, a small part of me had believed her. Perhaps I had failed. Perhaps more money, more excitement, a trip to Cabo, could have persuaded her to stay. Perhaps my children had received less than they should have.
“Dad?” Maisie said. “Is it okay?”
I drew out the neighboring chair and sat beside her.
“It’s your chair now,” I said. “If you want it.”
She considered that. Then she turned the tablet toward me.
The drawing wasn’t a horse.
It was our house: the little split-level, the backyard swing set, the maple blazing orange and red. Across the front stretched nine stick figures holding hands, some tall and some small.
One carried a guitar. One wore a uniform. One had a ponytail and purple braces.
At the end stood a tall figure beside a grill, a spatula in his hand.
Above them, she had written three purple words.
THE BETTER LIFE.
I studied it for a long while. Then, with my daughter in her chair beside me at our table, I put my arm around her and said nothing.
There was nothing left to add. She had already said it all.
Disclaimer: This story is a work of fiction inspired by real-life themes. Names, characters, places and events are fictionalized, and any resemblance to real persons is purely coincidental. Images are for illustration purposes only.
