PART 2: A Place That Wasn’t Promised
For several weeks, I tried to keep our household moving as though our lives hadn’t shifted. Lunches still needed packing, school forms needed signatures, and Caleb needed rides to baseball. I reminded Owen about his reading assignments. Every morning, Noah complained that his socks felt wrong. James continued abandoning his coffee mug beside the sink. Beneath all those ordinary things, one question remained: would the baby ever live with us?
Anna’s cousin was named Rebecca. She lived in Indiana with her husband and their two teenage children. Although she and Anna hadn’t been close recently, the family search had brought the baby to her attention. She wanted to find out whether she could care for her. I couldn’t blame her. She was family, entitled to ask questions and be considered. Still, when Rachel explained that Rebecca’s household would be assessed, something inside me seemed to fold inward.
James tried to keep his hopes up. “They haven’t made a decision.”
“I know.”
“We still have a chance.” I turned to face him. “That’s not the point. We keep talking about this baby as though we’re competing to win her.” Surprise crossed his face. “That’s not what I meant.”
“Then we need to stop saying things like that.”
He sat beside me. “You’re right.” I let out a breath. “I want her to be safe. I want her to be loved. I just wish I knew where that was going to happen.” James reached for my hand. “Me too.” Neither of us had expected waiting to feel this difficult. Rachel explained what she could about the process, but Rebecca’s private assessment information wasn’t hers to share.
The baby stayed in temporary care while the work continued. I checked my phone more often than I wanted to admit. An unfamiliar number appearing on the screen was enough to send my pulse racing. Finally, one afternoon, Rachel asked if James and I could come in. We sat opposite her in a small office, a tissue box between us.
Rebecca had decided not to continue seeking placement, Rachel explained. Learning more about the baby’s needs and the commitment ahead had helped her reach that decision. “She’s expressed that she hopes the child finds a loving, permanent family,” Rachel said. Relief rushed through me so intensely that guilt followed immediately. “Is she all right?” I asked.
Rachel nodded. “She’s made the decision she believes is right for her household.” James tightened his hand around mine. Then Rachel went on. “Your home study has been approved. We’d like to discuss the possibility of placing the baby with you as foster parents while the remaining legal proceedings continue.” I stared across the desk. “You mean she could come home with us?”

“Yes, if you’re both still willing.” James turned toward me. I thought of our sons, the broken nights, the unanswered questions. I thought about a little girl who could come into our home and still have to leave it someday. Then I nodded. “We’re willing.”
The next two weeks passed in a rush. Our office became a nursery. We put together a crib and bought bottles, diapers, and a car seat. At last, I opened the cardboard box in the garage. The boys’ old baby blankets were inside, including the white one my mother had embroidered with tiny blue stars. I held that blanket for a long time.
James discovered me sitting on the garage floor. “I thought we’d donated those things.”
“You kept saying next month.” A faint smile touched his mouth. “I guess I did.” I studied the blanket in my lap. “I thought we’d never need them again.” He crouched next to me. “Neither did I.”
For a moment, I was back in that same garage after Noah’s birth, sitting with James and mourning the daughter we believed we would never have. Then I folded the blanket and took it inside. The baby came to us on a Thursday afternoon. Rachel arrived with a diaper bag, medical records, and directions for the appointments ahead.
She seemed even smaller than I remembered. When I lifted her from the car seat, she opened her eyes, turning toward my voice. “Hello, sweetheart,” I whispered. James stood close, with all three boys gathered behind him in the hallway. “Can we see her?” Owen asked. “One at a time,” James said.
Caleb approached first and examined her with solemn attention. “She’s really little.”
“She is.”
“Can I hold her?”
“When we’re sitting down and I can help you.” Noah leaned around my arm. “Does she have teeth?” I laughed. “Not yet.” Disappointment crossed his face. “How does she eat chicken nuggets?” For the first time in weeks, my laughter came without immediate fear of whatever might follow.
Little by little, she found her place in our household. There were nights without enough sleep, bottles warming at two in the morning, and disagreements over whose turn it was to empty the diaper trash. Caleb grew protective. Owen enjoyed picking out her pajamas. Noah felt personally responsible for introducing her to every toy dinosaur in his collection.
James was wonderful with her. When she fussed, he paced the hallway with her in his arms, humming the same melody that had soothed our sons. Yet the deeper our attachment became, the more afraid I felt. We were her foster family, not her permanent family. Every appointment brought another reminder that her future remained under consideration.
Three months after she moved in, Rachel called. Proceedings involving the baby’s father had been delayed. I listened as she explained that the agency could not promise a date for resolving permanency. “Could she be moved?” I asked. “I can’t rule out changes in placement, Emily. But there isn’t a current plan to move her.” I thanked her and ended the call.
Then I went to the garage. The cardboard box remained where we had left it, nearly empty except for a handful of things I hadn’t put away. I lowered myself onto the floor beside it. Twenty minutes later, James found me. “Emily?” I lifted my head. “I can’t do this.” He crouched down. “Do what?”
“Keep loving her more every day while knowing someone could decide she belongs somewhere else.” He sat beside me. “I know it’s hard.”
“No, James. You don’t get to tell me it’s hard like I’m being unreasonable. You brought me into this. You asked me to open our home, our marriage, and our sons’ hearts to a child we might have to say goodbye to.”
He looked wounded. “We made that decision together.”
“After you stood in a hospital and told a social worker you wanted her.” He turned his face away. I knew I had hurt him. But I was terrified, and my fear had sharpened into cruelty.
“I didn’t know what else to do,” he said quietly. “Anna was gone. That baby was alone. I thought if we could help, we should at least try.”
“And what if trying isn’t enough?” He rubbed his face. “Then we’ll have to live with that.” I stared at him. “You make it sound so simple.”
“It’s not simple. I love her too.” His voice cracked. “Do you think I don’t lie awake wondering whether she’ll still be here next Christmas?” I looked at him and finally recognized the fear he had been carrying. It was the same as mine, only expressed differently.
“I’m sorry,” I whispered. He shook his head. “Don’t apologize for being scared.” I leaned into him. For a long time, we stayed on the garage floor while the boys played outside in the backyard. Eventually, I said what I had been afraid to acknowledge. “I don’t want to lose another daughter I never got to raise.” James drew me closer. “I know.”
The next week, Rachel asked us to attend a meeting about the baby’s long-term future. The assessment of available relatives was finished, and the outstanding legal matters were progressing toward resolution. Adoption, she explained, could become the permanency plan if the court authorized the necessary steps. I refused to celebrate. Not yet. Everything still depended on what happened next.
