PART 3: Walking Down
For a moment, words wouldn’t come. “No,” I said finally. “I’m her daughter. I’m Wren.” “Wren,” he said. His trembling right hand touched my face. “You have her chin,” he said. “Are you Harlan?” I asked. “Harlan Pike?” Barely a nod. “Stroke,” he said. His words were slurred. “Thursday. I think. I went down. Couldn’t get up. Dutch went for help.” He looked toward the dog. “He’s been gone four days,” Harlan said. “I thought he died.” Four days. Dutch hadn’t come uphill searching for food. He had been seeking help, starving and freezing behind my shed, waiting for someone. “He found me,” I said. “He leaned on me,” I said. “The first morning. His whole weight.” Harlan closed his eyes. “That’s what he does,” he said. “When he’s picked you.”
I lit Harlan’s stove with four matches, wrapped him in every available blanket, and warmed water for small sips. Behind the house stood his green Ford with a plow; keys hung on a nail. “I can’t carry you,” I said. “Don’t have to,” Harlan said. “Get the sled. In the shed. Pull me.” His hundred and forty pounds felt like a thousand as I dragged the wooden sled through snow to the truck. Somehow I maneuvered him into the passenger seat. Dutch jumped into the back. I remembered letter 15. Turn into the skid. Eleven miles downhill in a 1987 Ford, stroke victim beside me, three-legged dog behind, brought us to Tamarack Falls Regional Medical Center.
The doctors placed the stroke on Thursday. He had spent roughly ninety hours on the floor and was severely dehydrated and hypothermic. Another day would have killed him. Dr. Ana Ruiz, a kind-faced woman in her fifties, joined me in the waiting room. “Are you his granddaughter?” “No,” I said. “I’m his neighbor.” Her gaze moved over my plastic-covered sneakers, thin windbreaker, and army blanket. “Where do you live?” she asked. “Whitfield Ridge,” I said. “Three miles above him.” “Up there? Alone? In January?” “Since Saturday,” I said. She watched me quietly. “Who’s taking care of you?” she asked quietly. I had no answer at first. “My mother,” I said finally.
Dr. Ruiz let me sleep on the hospital family-lounge couch, brought a sandwich and coffee, and drove me to Margaret the next morning. She knew her; everyone in Tamarack Falls did. Above the Main Street hardware store, narrow stairs led to frosted glass with gold lettering: MARGARET FENN — ATTORNEY AT LAW. Margaret, sixty-five, wore short gray hair, chained reading glasses, and a cardigan with an elbow hole. She looked up from her desk, studied my face, and removed her glasses. “Oh,” she said quietly. “Oh, you’re Laurel’s girl.” I placed the trust envelope before her.
“I’ve been trying to find you,” Margaret said, “for sixteen months.” From a drawer she produced a thick folder containing copies of letters notifying me, as Laurel’s eighteen-year-old beneficiary, about the trust. The first bore October seventeenth of last year. “I sent one every month,” Margaret said. “Seventeen of them. Certified mail. To your father’s house. On Aspen Lane.” She turned the folder. Green receipts were attached. Sandra Maddox. Seventeen signatures. “I called the house,” Margaret said. “Eleven times. Your stepmother answered. She said you’d moved out. She said you were living in Denver. She said she’d pass along the message.” She shook her head. “I drove up there twice,” she said. “In November and December. She said you weren’t home.” “I was home,” I said. “I know.” “I was working doubles at the diner. Every weekend. Three blocks from here.” Margaret closed her eyes. “I never thought to look at the diner,” she said.
“How much?” I asked. She opened the documents. “Your mother’s life insurance paid out three hundred thousand dollars,” she said. “In 2015. The trust paid your father a monthly stipend for your care. Twelve hundred dollars. From age nine until you turned eighteen. A hundred and eight months.” Her eyes met mine. “A hundred and twenty-nine thousand, six hundred dollars,” she said. I stayed silent. “The rest was invested,” Margaret said. “Conservatively. Index funds. As of last month, the trust balance is two hundred and sixty-four thousand dollars.” She pushed a statement toward me. “Plus the cabin,” she said. “And forty acres on Whitfield Ridge. Which, by the way, the county appraised at three hundred and ten thousand last year.”
I stared. “Your mother asked me to keep records,” Margaret said quietly. “Of how the stipend was spent. She asked me to require receipts. Annually.” Another folder opened. “Your father provided them,” she said. “Every year. Until 2019.” “What happened in 2019?” “Your stepmother took over the reporting,” she said. “And the receipts stopped matching.” Each year listed fourteen thousand four hundred in support. In 2019, supposedly clothes, school supplies, and medical expenses, eleven thousand instead entered Sandra’s account for a Sea-Doo at Lake Dillon. In 2020, claimed clothing, school, and dental costs concealed ninety-two hundred for Tyler Maddox’s Colorado State tuition. In 2021, supposed food, clothing, and medical spending included twelve thousand eight hundred toward the Aspen Lane kitchen renovation. The greige.
“I’d been building a case,” Margaret said. “I was going to file in December. When you turned nineteen and had standing. But I couldn’t find you.” She paused. “And then on Saturday,” she said, “your father called me.” I went still. “My father?” “Saturday night,” Margaret said. “At eleven-forty. He was crying. He said he’d done something terrible. He said he’d left you on the ridge.” My breath stopped.
“He asked me if the cabin still had the cellar,” Margaret said. “He said Laurel told him once. Years ago. About a cellar. He couldn’t remember. He asked me if there was food up there.” She watched me. “I told him I didn’t know,” she said. “Harlan Pike handles the cellar. I told him I’d call Harlan.” “Did you?” “Harlan didn’t answer,” Margaret said. “Sunday. Monday. Tuesday. I was going to send the sheriff up this morning.” Then: “And then you walked in,” she said.
“He called you,” I said. “Saturday night.” “He did.” “Why didn’t he come back? Why didn’t he drive back up and get me?” She waited before answering. “Because Sandra told him not to,” she said quietly. “He told me that too. On the phone. He said, Sandra says she’ll be fine. Sandra says she needs to learn.” She shook her head. “He said, Margaret, I don’t know how to say no to her.”

That afternoon Dr. Ruiz drove me to Aspen Lane. Margaret accompanied us with Deputy Teresa Gomez, whom she had called to keep the peace. Beige two-story house. Three-car garage. A blue tarp covered a trailered jet ski in the driveway. I rang the bell. Sandra answered in yoga pants and fleece, coffee mug in hand. Seeing me drained her face. Seeing Margaret and the deputy drained it further. “Wren,” she said. “Honey. What are you—how did you—” “I walked,” I said.
Dad appeared behind her and stopped, studying my face—Mom’s chin, Mom’s eyes. He began crying. “Wren,” he said. “Oh, God. Wren. You’re okay. You’re okay.” Pushing past Sandra, he descended the steps to hug me. I moved backward. He stopped. “I need my box,” I said. He stared. “The shoebox,” I said. “Mom’s things. The photos. The tapes. The glass bird. You put it in your trunk.” He looked at Sandra; she studied the ground. “It’s in the garage,” my father said. “Get it,” I said. He went.
Sandra remained on the porch, looking between the deputy, Margaret, and the folder. “What is this?” she said. “What’s going on?” “Mrs. Maddox,” Margaret said. “I’m Margaret Fenn. I sent you seventeen letters. Certified mail. You signed for every one.” Sandra’s expression shifted. “I don’t know what you’re talking about.” Margaret raised the folder. “Seventeen green receipts,” she said. “Your signature. Every one.” Silence. “And these,” Margaret said, lifting bank records. “Eleven thousand dollars,” she said. “From Wren’s trust stipend. To your personal account. In 2019. The same month you bought that jet ski.” She indicated the driveway. “Nine thousand two hundred,” she said. “To your son’s tuition. Twelve thousand eight hundred. For your kitchen.”
Deputy Gomez stepped closer. “Mrs. Maddox,” she said. “Mrs. Fenn has filed a complaint with the district attorney. For misappropriation of trust funds and mail interference. I’m going to need you to come to the station and answer some questions.” Sandra’s mug fell and shattered on the porch.
Dad emerged carrying the taped gray Nike box marked WREN’S. He passed Sandra, the broken mug, and the jet ski before offering it to me. I opened it. Eleven photographs. Six tapes. Silver earrings. One tiny blue glass bird, wing still chipped. When I lifted it, afternoon sunlight cast a blue patch on the snow. Dad wept. “Wren,” he said. “I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. I called Margaret. Saturday night. I called her. I wanted to go back up. I wanted to—” “But you didn’t,” I said. He stopped. “You didn’t come back,” I said. His hands covered his face.
“Dad,” I said. He looked up. “Mom knew,” I said. “Ten years ago. She knew you’d do this.” His face collapsed. “She wrote me letters,” I said. “One for every birthday. She wrote one when I was seventeen that said you were a good man but not a strong one. She said you’d let somebody else decide everything. Because you couldn’t do it alone.” He sobbed. “She stocked the cellar, Dad,” I said. “Ten years ago. She knew someday you’d drive me up that mountain and leave me there. And she made sure I’d have enough to eat.” I raised the bird. “She took care of me,” I said. “From her grave. Because she knew you wouldn’t.”
His knees hit the snowy driveway before the neighbors, Sandra, Margaret, and Deputy Gomez. “I couldn’t do it alone,” he said. “After she died. I couldn’t—” “I was nine,” I said. “I did it alone.” He looked upward. “You had a choice, Dad,” I said. “Every day. For ten years. You could have said no. Once. Just once.” I looked toward Sandra. “You never did,” I said.
I pocketed the bird, tucked the box beneath my arm, and walked toward Dr. Ruiz’s car. “Wren,” my father said. I stopped without turning. “Where are you going?” he said. I thought of the cabin, stove, rug, cellar, Hazel’s stones, jam, letters, and tape. Harlan in his hospital bed, Dutch sleeping at its foot because Dr. Ruiz permitted it. “Home,” I said.
